| Name | Award | Year |
|---|---|---|
| Buck Dresden | Soldier of the Year | 2022 |
| Lux Aeterna | Team of the Year | 2022 |
| Lexi Gold | Newcomer of the Year | 2022 |
| Joshua Breedlove | Villain of the Year | 2022 |
| Carolina Lions Vs. Lux Aeterna | Match of the Year | 2022 |
| Buck Dresden | Hero of the Year | 2022 |
| Judy Punchinello Vs. Laura Seton | Feud of the Year | 2022 |
| Chick Grillbreast | Spit Your Game | 2022 |
| Breedlove Loses | Mark Out Moment of the Year | 2022 |
| Jamie Johnson | Champion of the Year | 2022 |
| RAIKO | Redemption Rumble | 2022 |
| NEMESIS | ApeX I | 2022 |
| Dan Stein Vs. Void | Feud of the Year | 2021 |
| Buck Dresden | Champion of the Year | 2021 |
| Void & Joshua Breedlove | Villain of the Year | 2021 |
| Unholy Cyber Army | Team of the Year | 2021 |
| Ayumi Comes Out | Mark Out Moment of the Year | 2021 |
| Dan Stein | Hero of the Year | 2021 |
| Azraith DeMitri | Soldier of the Year | 2021 |
| Lindsay Troy | Newcomer of the Year | 2021 |
| Lindsay Troy | Master of the Mat | 2021 |
| Breedlove Vs. The World | Feud of the Year | 2020 |
| Azraith DeMitri | Champion of the Year | 2020 |
| New Vanguard/Breedlove/Butcher | Villain of the Year | 2020 |
| Unholy Cyber Army | Team of the Year | 2020 |
| The Burial & Resurrection of Buck Dresden | Mark Out Moment of the Year | 2020 |
| Buck Dresden | Hero of the Year | 2020 |
| Buck Dresden | Soldier of the Year | 2020 |
| C.K. Butcher | Newcomer of the Year | 2020 |
| C.K. Butcher | Redemption Rumble | 2020 |
| Joshua Breedlove | Sin City Championship Series | 2020 |
| Maya Nakashima | Hero of the Year | 2013 |
| Jacob Mephisto | Villain of the Year | 2013 |
| Adrian Corazon Vs. Isaac Entragian | Feud of the Year | 2013 |
| Bad Ass Brotherhood | Team of the Year | 2013 |
| Jacob Mephisto | Sin City Championship Series | 2013 |
| Loco Martinez | Master of the Mat | 2013 |
| Elizabeth Gaunt | Newcomer of the Year | 2012 |
| Laura Seton Turns Heel | Mark Out Moment of the Year | 2012 |
| Isaac Entragian Vs. Jaime Alejandro | Feud of the Year | 2012 |
| Isaac Entragian | Villain of the Year | 2012 |
| Donovan King | Hero of the Year | 2012 |
| Jaime Alejandro Vs. Isaac Entragian | Match of the Year | 2012 |
| Bad Ass Brotherhood | Team of the Year | 2012 |
| Isaac Entragian | Champion of the Year | 2012 |
| Donovan King | Soldier of the Year | 2012 |
| Lunatikk Crippler | Sin City Championship Series | 2011 |
| Tag Team Division | Disappointment of the Year | 2010 |
| Azrael Goeren | Newcomer of the Year | 2010 |
| Jester Smiles Betrays the SHOOT Project | Mark Out Moment of the Year | 2010 |
| Cade Sydal (IF) Azraith DeMitri (WHC) | Champion of the Year | 2010 |
| Bad Ass Brotherhood | Team of the Year | 2010 |
| Sovereign Vs. SHOOT Project | Feud of the Year | 2010 |
| Adrian Corazon Vs. Trey Willett | Match of the Year | 2010 |
| Donovan King | Villain of the Year | 2010 |
| Trey Willett | Hero of the Year | 2010 |
| Donovan King | Soldier of the Year | 2010 |
| Adrian Corazon | Champion of the Year | 2009 |
| Dan Stein | Redemption Rumble | 2012 |
| X-Calibur | Redemption Rumble | 2011 |
| Donovan King | Redemption Rumble | 2009 |
| Jonny Johnson | Redemption Rumble | 2008 |
| Chris Lee | Redemption Rumble | 2002 |
| Trey Willett | Master of the Mat | 2011 |
| Azraith DeMitri | Master of the Mat | 2010 |
| Jester Smiles | Master of the Mat | 2008 |
| Del Carver | Master of the Mat | 2002 |
