| CHAMPION | FROM | UNTIL | DAYS HELD | NOTES |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NEMESIS | 04/06/2022 | #NUM! | ||
| Kale Tanev | 05/26/2014 | 11/08/2014 | 166 | |
| Lunatikk Crippler | 05/12/2014 | 05/26/2014 | 14 | |
| Dave Marz | 10/06/2013 | 05/12/2014 | 218 | |
| TMB | 08/19/2013 | 10/06/2013 | 48 | |
| Mr. Ocelot | 08/05/2013 | 08/19/2013 | 14 | |
| Solomon Richards | 06/29/2013 | 08/05/2013 | 37 | |
| Isaac Entragian | 10/01/2012 | 06/29/2013 | 271 | |
| Maya Nakashima | 02/05/2012 | 10/01/2012 | 239 | |
| Mason Pierce | 10/09/2011 | 02/05/2012 | 119 | |
| Cronos Diamante | 07/31/2011 | 10/09/2011 | 70 | |
| Alex Brooks | 02/10/2011 | 07/31/2011 | 171 | |
| Jun Kenshin | 7/15/2006 | 10/01/2006 | 78 | |
| Eli Storm | 6/9/2006 | 7/15/2006 | 36 | |
| Ray Willmott | 4/29/2006 | 6/9/2006 | 41 | |
| The Poe | 4/22/2006 | 4/29/2006 | 7 | |
| Ray Willmott | 4/15/2006 | 4/22/2006 | 7 | |
| The Poe | 3/10/2006 | 4/15/2006 | 36 | |
| Chris Lee | 2/5/2006 | 3/10/2006 | 33 | |
| Ron Barker | 11/18/2005 | 2/5/2006 | 79 | |
| MiRAGE | 10/28/2005 | 11/18/2005 | 21 | |
| Trey Willet | 10/6/2005 | 10/28/2005 | 22 | |
| Ayumi Seppuku | 9/25/2005 | 10/6/2005 | 11 | |
| Osbourne Kilminster | 8/18/2005 | 9/25/2005 | 38 | |
| Chris Lee | 7/10/2005 | 8/18/2005 | 39 | |
| Osbourne Kilminster | 6/2/2005 | 7/10/2005 | 38 | |
| OutKast | 5/1/2005 | 6/2/2005 | 32 | Won Master of the Mat 2005 to win the vacated Rule of Surrender title by beating Osbourne Kilminster in the finals. |
| Eryk Masters | 9/15/2002 | 11/1/2002 | 47 | |
| John Mathews | 9/1/2002 | 9/15/2002 | 14 | |
| Will James | 8/23/2002 | 9/1/2002 | 9 | |
| Eddie E | 7/14/2002 | 8/23/2002 | 40 | |
| Diamond Del Carver | 6/30/2002 | 7/14/2002 | 14 | |
| Real Deal Josh Johnson | 4/21/2002 | 6/30/2002 | 70 | |
| Chris Lee | 1/20/2002 | 4/21/2002 | 91 | |
| Ravage | 11/11/2001 | 1/20/2002 | 70 |
